I consider myself to be an A Christmas Carol aficionado. A Dickens fan, I read the book every December and have seen movie versions starring Alastair Sim, Reginald Owen, George C. Scott, Patrick Stewart, Guy Pearce, Jim Carrey, Michael Caine (with the Muppets), and, of course, Mister Magoo (Jim Backus.)
We can now add Johnny Depp to the list.
Many of the film adaptations are remarkably true to the written version. And why not? The story is written like a movie script, with so many famous quotes, it’s a shame to leave any of them out. And that’s what makes Ebenezer special.
Johnny Depp is unrecognizable as Scrooge. He does a terrific job in the role, as does Ian McKellen as Jacob Marley. We get to know Jacob a bit better than usual and get the impression that Scrooge views him as a greedy role model, not just a late partner in the counting house.
As in the book, the introduction of each ghost is titled on screen as a numbered stave. There is a consensus that Charles Dickens called the chapters of A Christmas Carol "staves" to echo musical staves and carol structure.
The ghosts are creepier and more otherworldly than most, wonderfully made up and costumed. Special effects are solid, not just the usual walking-through-doors variety.
Throughout the film, characters are portrayed with depth and sensitivity, revealing new details not included in the Dickens manuscript. This is important if you’ve grown somewhat weary of the original, rehashed by new faces and voices, but generally reciting text verbatim to the point that you can say the words yourself. Purists might not like this. I found it, if not like a sequel, to be a refreshing new take on exhausted material.
The Cratchits spend less time on screen, as does nephew Fred’s gathering of friends. But Belle and Fan are front and center, as they should be, given their central role in Ebenezer’s evolution and regrets. And don’t fear, Tiny Tim still blesses “Every one!”
The morning following the ghostly redemption gets a more serious treatment, with a more reasonably self-aware Ebenezer, and a less cruel surprise awaiting poor Bob.’
If you need to see a steaming pudding fresh from the copper, or those business associates who “must be fed” to attend a funeral, then this version is not for you. Otherwise, add this to your holiday viewing. I think you’ll find it bears repeating.
Ebenezer runs 1 hour, 55 minutes and is rated PG-13
* * * * *
The two books below belong to the "Park Ridge Memories" series which portrays life during the 1960s, 1970s, and beyond. Collections of true stories take you from the Cuban Missile Crisis to The Summer of Love, Hot Dog Day to a trip down I-57 at 137mph, with lots of other stops in between. These books are about a place, but also a time, and lots of shared memories. Click on the images to find out more.















